Welcome to Over Easy Cafe
At Over Easy Cafe, nestled in the heart of Sanibel, we believe that breakfast is more than just a meal; it's an experience. Our story unfolds in a cozy corner of the island, where a commitment to freshness and flavor meets warm, welcoming service. With a menu highlighting American classics, from hearty omelets filled with shrimp and Havarti cheese to irresistible Pina Colada French toast, each dish is crafted with love. Locals and visitors alike rave about our homemade goods, particularly the delightful raspberry jam. Here, every meal feels like a cherished tradition, making Over Easy Cafe a must-visit destination for unforgettable breakfast and brunch.
-
630 Tarpon Bay Rd #1, Sanibel, FL 33957 Hotline: (239) 966-5114
Welcome to Over Easy Cafe, a charming haven nestled in the heart of Sanibel, Florida. Situated at 630 Tarpon Bay Rd #1, this delightful breakfast and brunch spot is more than just a meal; it’s a delicious experience waiting to unfold. With a menu that radiates the comforting flavors of American breakfast classics, Over Easy Cafe has quickly become a beloved destination for locals and tourists alike.
The ambiance is cozy and inviting, making it the perfect place to start your day. As you stroll through the door, you’re instantly greeted by friendly staff, creating an atmosphere that feels like home. If you're wondering what to choose from their enticing offerings, you're in for a treat. Some highlights include:
- Hickory Smoked BBQ Pulled Pork Sliders: Mini sandwiches packed with flavor, served with crispy dill pickles—only $9.99.
- Coconut Shrimp: Enjoy six crunchy bites served with a delightful homemade mixed berry dipping sauce for just $9.99.
- Pina Colada French Toast: An extravagant breakfast bread infused with coconut and topped with a zesty pineapple sauce that has garnered rave reviews from guests.
- Sanibel Omelet: A longtime favorite featuring shrimp and havarti cheese, a must-try for anyone who loves a hearty and flavorful breakfast.
Their commitment to quality and flavor is evident in every dish, with many customers raving about the freshness and creativity of their meals. For example, one patron shared that the veggie omelet is the best they've ever tasted, and the homemade raspberry jam is simply heavenly!
Don’t just take my word for it—guests like Mikaela D. have praised the restaurant for its fantastic food and excellent service, while Grumpy B. appreciates its family-run charm and the amazing homemade salsa. Whether you're in the mood for a quick breakfast before heading out to explore Sanibel's stunning beaches or a leisurely brunch with friends, Over Easy Cafe is sure to satisfy.
Next time you find yourself on Sanibel Island, make sure to stop by Over Easy Cafe for an unforgettable breakfast or brunch experience. From their famous breakfast dishes to their warm and welcoming staff, this hidden gem is definitely worth seeking out!
Great lunch stop on Sanibel! Both the food and service are fantastic. Their house special "Rusty Pelican" sandwich was delicious.
Loved everything about this place. Good was great & server was so nice. Learned a lot about the beautiful island
A lovely family run business. The homemade salsa was outstanding. Breakfast was better than expected, and the staff are all friendly. This place is in a small strip mall, but it is worth seeking out. If we were ever back on the island we would return.
Came to the cafe for breakfast. Very cute restaurant tucked in the corner of the newly renovated plaza. The service is quick, food fresh, and they have great menu of offerings!
We first ate at the Sanibel Cafe on our honeymoon, 30 years ago! We loved it. Today we went back for the first time. It was everything we remembered. We ordered what we had 30 year's ago. The Sanibel Omelet, which has shrimp and havarti cheese in it. It is so delicious. They also serve this amazing raspberry jam with the toast. It is so good! The service is so very welcoming. This remains one of our favorite places. I can't recommend it enough!!!
We had a wonderful breakfast here at Sanibel Café. Upon walking in the door, we were directed to sit at a table immediately and was greeted by the welcoming staff. The breakfast menu had so many options to choose from including specialty flavors of French toast which intrigued us the most. Our eggs and meat were cooked exactly how we asked and the food was delicious! When we went to the front desk to pay our tab, they had shelves full of homemade goods which was a nice addition to the overall atmosphere. We ended up purchasing the pineapple jelly and it was so so so good! This hidden gem will definitely receive our business again if we ever find ourselves visiting on Sanibel island.
We go to Sanibel Cafe often- the best breakfast on the Island! But I had never tried the Pina Colada French toast! It's the best thing I've had in 'breakfast breads'. Not only dipped in egg, cinnamon and nutmeg, it's got coconut all over it. They are generous with it. 4 pc in a serving and then the pineapple sauce over it is so yummy! I added some syrup on a couple of bites but it doesn't need it- gotta give it a try or order some for all the table to try with their generous egg dishes! Service is wonderful and buy a jelly as you leave, raspberry is my favorite!
We decided on eating here the last morning of our vacation and are so glad we did. Thanks to Pat, we had an amazing time. I'm glad brunch options were available as I'm not a breakfast person. The grilled chicken sandwich was very plentiful, juicy, and a great value with the fries. The turkey croissant with jam and coleslaw was nice according to my husband who also enjoyed the parm tomatoes as sides. The business has a rush in the mornings that subsides before 12. Keep that in mind on weekends. Great people here.
What a beautiful spot! Came from Philadelphia for a week and was searching for breakfast places. This place is a jewel: the atmosphere, food, and staff are amazing. First class service. I had the veggie omelette, which is for sure the best I ever had. And dont forget to try their raspberry jam made in house. Heaven. The flight from Philly is worth it just for the food! RF